When veterans file for disability compensation, the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) requires proof that their condition is related to military service. Sometimes this is straightforward — an injury or illness that happened while on active duty. Other times, it’s more complicated, especially when veterans seek benefits for obesity as a secondary condition.
A recent case has shed new light on how the VA views obesity claims, particularly when they’re tied to service-connected conditions such as post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Let’s break it down.
The Veteran’s Claim for Obesity as a Secondary Condition
In this case, a U.S. Air Force veteran (1966–1970) filed a claim for service connection for obesity as secondary to his service-connected PTSD. His reasoning was clear: PTSD can contribute to weight gain through depression, stress, and changes in eating habits.
The veteran supported his claim with medical articles linking stress hormones like cortisol to obesity. He also provided records showing obesity-related issues, including postural problems and reliance on a rollator.
Despite this evidence, the VA denied the claim, arguing that the veteran had not submitted “new and relevant” information to reopen his original case.
Why the VA Denied the Obesity Claim
The VA Board’s denial was based on a longstanding position: obesity is not considered a disease or disability for VA purposes. Instead, VA regulations treat it as a “risk factor” that can contribute to other conditions, but not as a disability in itself.
The Board leaned on a VA General Counsel opinion, which concluded that:
- Obesity is not a disease or injury under VA rules.
- Obesity cannot be service-connected on its own or as a secondary condition.
- Functional impairment (such as reduced ability to work) must be tied to a recognized disease or injury—not obesity.
In short, the VA’s position was: even if obesity affects a veteran’s earning capacity, it cannot be service-connected because it is not defined as a disease.
The Question of Functional Impairment
This case raises an important issue: what happens when obesity directly limits a veteran’s ability to work?
Think about jobs that require physical fitness, like law enforcement or construction. If a veteran’s weight issue is secondary to PTSD or a service-connected knee injury, and that obesity prevents them from meeting job requirements, isn’t that a functional impairment?
Courts have emphasized that VA compensation is supposed to address functional impairment of earning capacity. In this case, the Court suggested that obesity may qualify as a disability if the veteran can show it causes functional impairment.
This distinction is critical: while obesity itself may not be recognized as a disease, the functional limitations it creates could still matter.
The Role of Causation in Obesity Claims
Another important factor is causation. Veterans need to show a clear link:
- “But for” the primary service-connected condition, the veteran would not have developed obesity.
For example:
- PTSD leads to depression and overeating, which results in obesity.
- A knee injury limits mobility, which contributes to weight gain and obesity.
Establishing this “but for” connection is essential. Without it, the VA is unlikely to grant service connection.
Why Medical and Occupational Evidence Matters
Winning a VA claim for obesity as a secondary condition requires more than just medical records showing weight gain. Veterans must also demonstrate how their obesity creates functional impairment.
This is where evidence becomes crucial:
- Medical opinions should link the primary condition (such as PTSD) to obesity.
- Occupational assessments can show how obesity limits a veteran’s ability to perform specific job duties.
- Daily life impact statements can provide insight into how obesity restricts mobility, social interactions, or overall health.
By combining medical and functional evidence, veterans have a stronger chance of overcoming the VA’s restrictive interpretation.
What This Case Means for Veterans
The takeaway from this case is twofold:
- Obesity is not automatically excluded from VA consideration. While the VA has long argued that obesity is not a disease, courts have pushed back, requiring the VA to consider whether obesity functionally impairs a veteran’s earning capacity.
- Secondary conditions matter. Veterans should always list not only their primary service-connected condition but also any related secondary issues—including obesity—when filing a claim.
Remember the old phrase, “the knee bone’s connected to the hip bone”? That’s exactly how the VA should view secondary conditions. A knee injury may lead to a hip problem, which may lead to back pain, which may lead to obesity due to limited mobility. Everything is connected.
Moving Forward: How to Strengthen Obesity Claims
If you’re a veteran considering filing for obesity as a secondary condition, here are some steps to take:
- Document everything. Keep records of weight changes, mobility issues, and job performance challenges.
- Seek medical support. Ask your healthcare providers to note the connection between your service-connected condition and your obesity.
- Get an occupational assessment. Professionals can evaluate how obesity affects your ability to perform your job duties.
- Don’t ignore secondary conditions. Even if the VA initially denies your claim, including secondary conditions like obesity keeps the door open for future appeals.
Conclusion: Obesity and VA Disability Claims
The VA’s stance on obesity remains complex, but this case shows that obesity is not automatically excluded from service connection. The key is demonstrating functional impairment and proving that obesity stems from a primary service-connected condition.
For veterans, this means that while the road may be challenging, it’s not impossible. With strong evidence, occupational assessments, and a clear demonstration of functional impairment, obesity can and should be considered in VA disability claims.
Contact Us for Help!
If you need assistance with VA claims, complete this form or give us a call at (229) 226-8183. If you’d like to see this blog in video format, you can watch it below. Please be sure to SUBSCRIBE to our YouTube channel and click the bell notification button so that you’re notified each time we publish a new video.